Slip and Fall

Ville Platte Hospital Found Not Liable for Ant Bites on ICU Patient

Published on: March 20, 2023 | By Berniard Law Firm

ant_dod_pomonkey_2015-scaled Hospital admission can often be a terrifying experience, but even more so is an ICU admission. Your life is literally in the hands of hospital doctors and nurses. But what happens if you sustain injuries unrelated to your original illness or injury while in the ICU? A recent patient at Mercy Regional Medical Center in Ville Platte, Louisiana, was left with no legal recourse after sustaining multiple ant bites during her ICU stay.

Linda Searile was admitted to Mercy Regional Medical Center (Mercy Regional) in September 2011 after falling and hitting her head. After her condition deteriorated, she was moved to the ICU. Two days later, a nurse discovered ants on Ms. Searile’s arm and in her bed. The nurse removed the ants and gave Ms. Searile medication for pain and itching. Ms. Searile was discharged from Mercy Regional a few days later.

Ms. Searile filed a lawsuit against Mercy Regional, asserting the hospital knew or should have known of the ant infestation and should have taken reasonable steps to eliminate the bugs. Mercy Regional filed a motion for summary judgment stating that Ms. Searile could not show that the hospital was negligent in any manner and that the lawsuit should be dismissed entirely. The Thirteenth Judicial District Court for the Parish of Evangeline agreed with Mercy Regional and dismissed the case. Ms. Searile appealed to the Louisiana Third Circuit Court of Appeal.

When Can I File a Tort Lawsuit against my Employer if I am Hurt at Work in Louisiana?

Published on: March 14, 2023 | By Berniard Law Firm

forklift_machine_crane_1645850-scaled Workers’ compensation is a financial support system that may be available to injured employees. It aims to ensure employees are compensated for their injuries and do not bear the entire expenses of medical bills. Workers’ compensation laws differ from state to state. Still, the general idea is that employees can get benefits regardless of who was at fault for the injury so long as the injury arose from an act during employment.

While workers’ compensation provides employees a safety net, not all claims fall under the statutory regime. Sometimes plaintiffs, like David Lindsay, believe that their injury might result from an intentional act by their employer, which could allow for a more significant damage award. Those workers will try to file their workplace accidents as intentional tort claims. The following case from the First Circuit in Louisiana discusses how employees try to recover damages outside of Workers’ Compensation benefits for their injuries on the job. It also helps answer the question, when can I file a tort claim against my employer if I am hurt at work in Louisiana?

David Lindsay was an employee at Packaging Corporation of America (PCA), where he operated forklifts as part of his duties. He suffered severe injuries when the forklift he was driving slipped and fell off a loading dock. This accident lodged his left forearm between a railcar and the safety cage on the forklift.

Louisiana Restaurant Evades Liability For Speculative Slip-and-Fall Claim

Published on: March 6, 2023 | By Berniard Law Firm

slip_up_danger_careless-scaled Slip-and-fall cases are prevalent in the restaurant industry. In handling various kinds of food and drink, it makes sense that sometimes, things end up on the floor and can cause a slip hazard for customers. But when a customer falls without a clear cause, how can the court determine who is at fault?

Laurita Guillory sued Barco Enterprises (“Barco”), owner of The Chimes Restaurant, after a fall at their restaurant. Guillory alleged that, when visiting the restaurant, she slipped and fell by the wait station. She claimed that a mysterious substance was spilled on the floor by the restaurant waitstaff, and it caused her fall. With these allegations, Guillory filed a lawsuit under the Merchant Liability Statute.

Based on the assertion that Guillory failed to prove her allegation sufficiently, Barco filed a motion for summary judgment and supported it with several documents and affidavits. These documents included testimony from Guillory that she never saw anything spilled on the floor by the waitstaff and a manager’s affidavit stating that nothing on the floor could have caused a fall. The trial court granted the motion because Guillory failed to show that the restaurant had caused a dangerous condition or knew about a hazardous situation. Guillory appealed the trial court’s decision dismissing her lawsuit.

Pineville Wal-Mart Not Liable For Customer Who Slipped During Rainstorm

Published on: February 14, 2023 | By Berniard Law Firm

louisiana_arrows_art_students-scaled Imagine going shopping at your local Wal-Mart or other store and slipping and falling because there is standing water. You might think you can recover from the store for your injuries. However, simply showing that you slipped and fell is not enough to win in court. Rather, you must present sufficient evidence about the store’s involvement and knowledge of the unsafe conditions.

Bethany Dubroc entered a Walmart in Pineville, Louisiana, while it was raining. While reaching for a prescription in her wallet, Dubroc slipped and fell. After she fell, Dubroc noticed that there was water on the floor. Dubroc sued Wal-Mart in the District Court for the Western District of Louisiana.

Walmart moved for summary judgment, arguing Dubroc’s case should be dismissed because Dubroc did not provide evidence that Walmart either created or had actual or constructive knowledge of the water that allegedly caused Dubroc to slip and fall. In response, Dubroc argued that employees at Walmart did not follow Walmart’s Inclement Weather Policy. This Inclement Weather Policy required that Wal-Mart employees every fifteen minutes and wipe down wet shopping carts every fifteen minutes. However, for the hour before the time Dubroc fell, no Wal-Mart associate mopped the area where she fell or wiped down the shopping carts. Dubroc presented evidence, including surveillance video, deposition testimony, and witness statements. However, none of this evidence provided insight into how long the water had been on the floor at Wal-Mart prior to Dubroc’s fall.