The Contamination Crisis:
In 2012, Cedar Lodge discovered their pond had been contaminated with sewage, evidenced by high levels of fecal coliform bacteria. The source was traced back to the adjacent Fairway View Apartments. Cedar Lodge’s plans to develop their property into a residential and commercial community were shattered, leading them to sue the apartment owners and their sewage treatment contractor.
Legal Twists and Turns:
-
Expert Witness Drama: The district court initially excluded Cedar Lodge’s environmental expert, Suresh Sharma, from testifying. This decision was later overturned on appeal, except for opinions related to specific federal standards.
-
Summary Judgment for the Defendants: The district court granted summary judgment to Fairway View Apartments, dismissing Cedar Lodge’s claims. The court reasoned that there was insufficient evidence of damage, even though contamination had occurred.
-
Appeal and Partial Reversal: The Court of Appeals partially reversed the district court’s decision, finding that there were genuine issues of material fact regarding Cedar Lodge’s negligence and nuisance claims. The case was remanded for further proceedings.
Key Takeaways:
-
Environmental Disputes and Property Rights: This case underscores the importance of environmental responsibility and the rights of property owners to be free from contamination caused by neighboring entities.
-
The Role of Expert Witnesses: The admissibility of expert testimony can significantly impact the outcome of a case. The appeals court’s decision to allow Sharma’s testimony demonstrates the importance of carefully evaluating an expert’s qualifications and the relevance of their opinions.
-
Damages in Environmental Cases: Determining damages in environmental cases can be complex. While regulatory standards are important, they don’t necessarily dictate the extent of damages a property owner can recover.
The Fight Continues: The legal battle between Cedar Lodge and Fairway View is far from over. The case has been remanded to the district court, where a jury will decide whether Fairway View is liable and what damages, if any, should be awarded to Cedar Lodge.
Additional Sources: CEDAR LODGE PLANTATION, L.L.C., v. CSHV FAIRWAY VIEW I, L.L.C.; CSHV FAIRWAY VIEW II, L.L.C.; CAMPUS ADVANTAGE, INCORPORATED; SEWER TREATMENT SPECIALISTS, L.L.C.,
Written by Berniard Law Firm
Other Berniard Law Firm Blog Articles on Toxic Spills: Petroleum Corporation Releases Millions of Gallons of Toxins Harming Many in Calcasieu Parish and Appellate Court Affirms Trial Court’s Approval of Settlement Agreement in Property Contamination Lawsuit